WPC~ W ڞv1t#TWPw@3?+_f%Π-j}hCza񧳾}|Yrɜޒ-QLZ;43փ>Br O"<̐оT&\=_{} ]TNsGPWNHcw8*ܑp9nTq%B-?92dPx̍ǵB)A1\y瘪~ Vo*2ĜQS<#s8vsS Pn7D`f"` zi3aiM@Ö&?pR /.iV{УgD7OND. 6O*B<&rU &iӯ^Qc\s$7&rPɨ=%JpPT{rRyٲ~0GosrƽšSORdxtpTy> h ? hC? hS? hCY?Y?Y?Y?Y?"??????DDGGGGGbFK{NKNKLLLLLLLLMMM[N[N[N1NN+UXX`YY'E[l\k`aa.b.bcccdddd%g-h-h-hx5h5h5h5h5h5h5h5h5h5h5h,jjjjjjj{{}HP LaserJet 5 - StandardHPPCL5G,,,,0nL(hH  Z 6Times New Roman RegularX($0MyAArial Bold #$%U&D'D()U*D+D,:_G#3|x,C:\WINDOWS\TEMPLATE\STANDARD.WPT,  AZ"Arial Regular2  aZ2Letter Gothic Regular  H (9 Z 6Times New Roman Regular(3$ !     d C:\WINDOWS\TEMPLATE\STANDARD.WPTC:\OFFICE\WPWIN\TEMPLATE\STANDARD.WPT ,wFAZ"Arial RegularTABLE A d((3$ !      0  (#$  0  >c$"Small Circle"0 - -   $    1    ݀&4&XXTheCommissionalsoobservesthattheuseofanyothertechniquetocreateachildgenetically  identicaltoanexisting(orpreviouslyexisting)individualwouldraisemany,ifnotall,ofthesamenonsafetyrelatedethicalconcernsraisedbythecreationofachildbysomaticcellnucleartransfer.: 8Word222Null     !!XXXX       !!XXXX  0 .Normal     !!XXXX       !!XXXX  - - 9  $    2    ݀Asomaticcellisanycelloftheembryo,fetus,child,oradultwhichcontainsafull  complementoftwosetsofchromosomes;incontrastwithagermcell,i.e.,aneggorasperm,whichcontainsonlyonesetofchromosomes.   $    3    ݀WithrespecttointerestingfictionconsiderAldousHuxley'sBraveNewWorld(1932),  DavidRorvik'sunsubstantiatedclaimofsuccessfulhumancloninginInHisImage(1978),and  popularfilmssuchasTheBoysfromBrazil(1978)andJurassicPark(1993)inwhichcloning  leadstodire,doomsdayconsequences.0 .Footer       !!XXXX         !!XXXX  : 8WP Defaults     SI` hp x (#%'0*,.8135@8:S!!9XX9XX       SI` hp x (#%'0*,.8135@8:S!!9XX9XX  &0 d d& $#  X   !!9XX9XX    X   !!9XX9XX  4 21, 2, 3,     !!9XX9XX       !!9XX9XX  C:\WINDOWS\TEMPLATE\STANDARD.WPT(3$ !  7165 I&mage <=8C HKKKKC:\WINDOWS\TEMPLATE\STANDARD.WPT'dxd( $ Figure  1  Level 1Level 2Level 3Level 4Level 5C:\WINDOWS\TEMPLATE\STANDARD.WPT- -C:\OFFICE\WPWIN\TEMPLATE\STANDARD.WPT .  4  ]I` hp x (#%'0*,.8135@8:X]X&XXX&,&XX&ԀMuchofthischapterisderivedfromthematerialcontainedintwocommissionedpapersprovidedby  JanetRossant,SamuelLunenfeldResearchInstitute,MountSinaiHospital,Toronto;andbyStuartOrkin,ChildrensHospitalandDanaFarberCancerInstitute,Boston.#&4&&&,y#& &&&4  =C:\WINDOWS\AFILES\REPORT\FINAL\REPLACE1.TIFWPC9 &}(  ?r ?r ?r ?r r r r r r@??p??|8`a?8???À> |?o??|0?p@?!p0>?? ? 8o?|?|> ?? ?  ??~@ ?o?||>???!?|?~!???~>|~C |?o????|??????????> o??|???~???~?????> o??|??~?~????> o??|?~????>? q?||?|?~?|??>? q?|?|??|??~?|??>? p?|?|??|???~?|??>? p?|?|??|???~?|??>? ?o?|?|??|??~?|??>? o?|?0|??|??~?|?? >? o?|?|??|?????>? o?|??|??|??p???>? o?|?|?|?Çp???>? o?|?~????0????>? o?|~??!~??|??>? o??|?~????!????>? o????|??!???>? o?|??????|??~?????>? ~o?C|??!????>? o?| ?????!????>? o ?|0p?À??a????? 8??o > !?~ >??-'<<<~ ?x>? |~>x ?~? ?>?|?>-'~??| ?? !?? ?~? ??~.'??| ? !? |~? ?~.'????| ?? !?? ~?? ~.'??x ?? !? !?~?.'??x ?? !?? "~.'?x ?? !? "~.'x ? ! "~.'x!?? ! "~?.'x!? ! "~.'??x??? ~~ .'??x???| ~? .'??x??? | ~ ? .'| ?? !| !|?~?? ?.'|! !| "|~???.'???|!???|? !?~?? ?.'>;?<?<~!?|;<?|??| !~ <;?|-'!< !~ -' ?< ??~ ?-' @!@> ~ @~-'`!???0? ~ ????-'!??~ ~x? ???.+,-)#?4+,-)#4)|?)?+'#4))+?'?#4))+??'#5))+'?"5))+'?"5)*+("5)?*?+(#5)+-)#5 ON?N?N?N?G ????????A??A?A???A???A|??@|??0@|??@|??@8??@8??@8??@?????@???@??????????"0?"  ?# ? #|?<?#??~?D#??~x?~?D"??~x~C!?~~C >~C!>C!>C >C?!>C?!?>?C$?>?$?>$?>$??~8??#??~8|?#?~x?|#?|~?#|?~?#?C"?" ?"???&&&&2?223333333?334444444?445555555?556666666?667777777?77888888888?88 665 5 ??5 ?4 4  4?4?33?3(3'~?2&}?2?&\?2%[2%[ ?2?$?Z? 2 $Y 2 $?Y ??1 $?Y?? 1 $Y? 1 #.' 1 #-?% 1 #-% 1 #-% ?1 ?)$? 1?  )?  1  (???0 ? ?(?0  !<0???00? |0??@00?x??/?w?/?/?/?/??/?/?/?. ?.? ~. ??.?  ?.?  .?  .  .  .  .?  .?  ?.  ?-  -? ?-? ?-  ??-??  ~-??  ??-?  ??-  ?-  -  -  -  -  -?  -?  -  -  -  ?- ? ?- ? ?- ? - ? -  -?  -?  ,??  ,??  ?,??  ?,??  ??,??  ??,?  ,?  ,  0,  ,  ,  ,  ,  ,   ,   ?,   , ?  ,   ,   ~,   ,   ,  ?,  ,   , ?  ?, ?  ,  ? ,   > ,   ?? ,    , ?   ,   ?,   ?,   ?,   ?, ?  ?, ??  ?,?? } ?,?  ?,? ? ?,? o ?,?  , ? , ,?  ,   ,   ,   ,   ,    ,  ,  8,  <,?  ?|,?p  |?,  ?,  ,  ,  ,?  ,??  ??,??  ?,?  ?,??  ?,??  ?,?  ,  , ? , ? ,? ? -?? ? -??   ?-?  ?-?  -?  -  -?  -C?  -?  @?-  ?-  ??-??  ?-?  -p?  ?~-?  ?-  ?? ? ????? ? ??? ???| ? ?? ?? >?? ?? ??p????? ?`? ??@?  ????~8?   ?x????0C  ? 0??? a ? x??? ???? 1??? ? ??| ???8 ? ? ????  ? ??! ?p?"?? ?p"ߏ ??@?"? ???x$? ??%?'? ?U ? ?U! ??V!1V"1V)0 1V)x ?1V) 1?W?) 2?W+ 2W+ 2Y+  2Y,  2  2!2??!2"1"?1?"1$1%?0?8?0??| ?  ?? ?? <? ? C?? ?    ? ?? ?? $?à $>?à $ $? #??   " "> "?> ;"> +!? ?* * ?? * ? + ? +  +  +  + ?~? +  + ? + ? + ? ?+  ?*  *  *?   +?   +   +  ? + ?? ? + ??  +  +++?*?**?))))?)?)))C?C Cq C ?q ? ?? q? ?? q? ??? ?? q ?$`?? ?? q $@ ?? q $ ?? p $?~ ?? p $ ?? p? $?~ ??? p $#?~ ???? p $!?~ ???pa p $!?>|? ??`! ?p $!?>|?8??@? p $a?>|?8????|p ?$|p?>|?8??p ?$xp?>|?x??p $xp?>|?x???p "8??x???o "8a?? ?>o? "0c?? ?>o? $C???>o $C>|???>o$G~???>o$~??a>0o$?? ?> o$? ?> o$? ?> o?$???l#?????l ??l? ??l?? ??|l? ??!?l? ?!?!l ???pxal ???xl B?` B@ ....?.....  ? ?Ak ?@?k @?j @j ??j     i     i    i? À>?? ?   ?i ?    ?i ?    ?i ??>|~    h? ?    ?h ???    h ?? '? ?h ???(|?c h? ?(8# ?h ?(~? ?h (~|???| h  '??? g?  '?~ ?g  '~ g ' ?g '?~ g? '?~ g ??? '?~ ?g ??C '?~ ??g ???C '?~   '?~  ?~ ~?~  ? ~?~   |?~  ? '?|? ?  '|? ? ? '?|? ?  '|?  ? '??~?|  ? '~#   '#    '8?c   ? '? ? ? ?$? ? $   $  $  -$  -$ -$ -$ b,$ b<,$  ?b?|?,;  ?b?,;  b?,; ? b,; ? b-; ? a-; ? a-;  a-;  a>);  a ( ? ? }>(  ? }>>(~  ? }>>?(~  ? }~?)|??   a)|?   a)|?   a)|?   a)~   `)~?   `)~   `)  ? `)?  ? `?)?  ? a>)  ? ad+>?d+>d+>?d?+>d?+>?e?+>?e?+??e+?e+?e+?e+??f+@f+@?f+Ag?+Ah?+?+?+?+?+++++A?g+A?g+A?f*A?f*A?f?*A?d?*A?d?(A?d?(A?d?(A?d(A?d(A?e?(A?e?(A?e ?(A?e(A?e(A?e(A?e)A?e)A?e)A?e?)A?e)A??e)A??e)A??e)A??e)A??e)A??e)A??f)A??f)A??f?)A??f?)A??f)A??f)A??f)A??f?)A??f?)A??f?)A??f)A??f)A??f)>???d?*???d*????d*?>?>?d*? ?@ ?e*?e*?e*?f*?f*?f*?*?*?*?*@@@@??@??@@@@@@@@AAAAA??AA*A)A(A(A(A(A?'B'B ??&B x&B & ????% O% % ?%%??$$$$A$@#@? #? #> #>~ #=C~? #= ? ~ #=  } #=  C| "<  ?| ?"< ? ?| "<  { "< ? ??{À? ?"<? ?{ ?"; { ";?? z "; ??z !; y? ?!;? y~? !;? ?y !;~ ?y!: ?  y!:?  ? y!:   y?!:   y!:   y!:?    y!: ? ? >x 9# ~! w 9 ? w??? 9 ?A w>?~? 9 ` w~>? 9  w| 9?  w 9  v 9 ? v 9  vǏ 9?  v 8>  vǃ 8|? < v 8| v 8?v 8?v 8v 8v 8\?? 8[ 8?Z 8~?Z 8Z 7Yp` 7?Y`? 7>?X ?7~??X ?7|?>X?7|>?X7~?X ~?7|?X>?7X?7X ?7X 7X 7X 7aqX 7xU 7|U 7|U 7|?U ?7~?U ?7?U ?7Ǐ??U ?7?U ?7?U ?7?U ?7?U ??6??U ?68??U ?6|>?U ?6|>?U 6|>?LJU ?6|>?U 6x<V 6x<V  6x<V 6x<V 6x<V ?| 6x<V ?~?q 6x<V ~?p 6x<V~? 6x?V~? 6|>?W> 6|>?W? 6|>?W8? 6|>?X? 6|>?X 6|>?X 6|>?Y 6~??Y? 6~??Y 6~??[ 6~??[ 6~??[ 6~??\ 6~??t 6>?tx 6?8t  6?<?u 7?~~?u? 7~?u?? 7~?t?>? 7~?t?~? 7~?t?| 7~?ux 7?u!7u!7u?!7u!7u!7v !7v !7``v !7@~?`v !7<>? v? ?!7? ??v !8???v? "8w? ?"8ÿw "8Çw "8w "8  w "8 ?> w ??"8 >? w? "8 |?? >?w #8ǀ  ~?x #8  x #8  y #8  y~ #8  y  #8  y??#8  z`#9 ? zp$9  pz$9  z$9 ? z$9 < >{?$9 ? {?$9  | ~%9 A `| %9  |  %9 ? | ?%:   } `&: ? ( } &: ?  ?} 8&:p   ?}':   ~': ? ? ?';? ?(;   (;   );< );>?? >?; ?; ?; ; < < ??< À<  = ? = 0 ?= ?y  <= ?>?>?????AA?B?&%jI%6*? +%5* +%5* +%5*? +%5*? +%5*? +%5*? +%5*? +%>???"'???!%e?0|`8?0'???À??!%e>8@?0?C  '?????!%e||?? '????|!%ex|?>??|?~>~π?'???~x?|~??!%e????|??~'??|?~?!%e???????||?>'??'????<~?!%=????|#|?>'??????!&A? ?0????|??)=??#$;>????$|?).? #$;>????$|?).??Ç #$f?>?????|?~'?????!%f?>????'????!%e~??|?|????>'??????!%e??>????|?~??'????~~????!%e????|?'????!%eC???|?CC'??!%e??0p?8$$?? M ?  $ ?? F ?  $ ?? E   $  ?? E ?  $  ? ? E   $  ? ? E   $  ? ? E ?  $  ? ? E ?  $  ? ? E   $???$a??? ?@?`,Y `!>??$b~?@??@+Y@?>?$b~~~?~?>???+Y?|??|~><$b??????????+Y???>?$bx?????+Y??>~$bx???????+Y???>~$b?????????+W???>~? $??????x?+(??x*><? $?????x+(?x+>|??x,X?x|?>|??x,X ?ax8?a><?$b????????+Y???>~$b?????????+Y?|?>~$b????????+Y???>$b??????????+Y???>?$b~~??????>?+Y?|????|?>~$a??????,Y??!>??$a???@,Y??!!! >?$a?? ? ?0`,Y a>??$I~924?9244924492449144814481?448?144%  (% k % j % j ) j '4?????WF?%6ÀpWQ????%6`?VR ??~??%6?@?VR??|??|~%6??VR?~?<|?~x?|~%6???VS???????|?~? %6?~|VSx?????>????<~?%5??~|????WQ??>???%?>8WL>>8WL>>8?VR>><?%6?>8VR>><??%6?>8VR>><?%6?>80VS>>< ?? %6?>VS>>US?>>??US>>???? %7?~???? %7?~|USp??>????? %6?~??VS?p???????? %6VS??????~~? %)?VR??????~%)VR??????%)pxWQ?? ????????%)??xWQ??~6~>~??6?p?~>~??6 >?|?5>?|?5>?|?5>?|?4>?|?4>?|?7?|??7?|?7!?|??7??`>~7?>>~??7?~>~7??~??7?~?~C7??~60~6p8>?6?>,?,??,,---- <  8 C            , C, , x,,?,--?--?--?-?PPPQQQQQQQQ?QQQQQQQQQ?QQRR::99?8888?7 7? 7?76?666665?55?5 5 5 5 5  4  ?4 ? 4  4  4  4  4  4  4  4  4  3 ? ?3 3 20 2` 2` 2 ?2 2 2 2? 2? 2 ??1 ? ?1  1<  ?1x  ?1x  ?0x  0  0  0  0  0  0  0  0  0  0  0  0` ?0p 00 10 1 1 ??1 ??1  ?1 ?1 ?1? ? 0?  0 0 0@ 0  10 10 18 18 1< 1< 1| 0|9[% 0|9?V??" 08Vx! 07?U?p?  ?07T  ?16 S  ?16 Q ??? ?16 88Q ?15 x<?P? ?15 x<P 14 `x8O?  14 88N?  14 80<N? g 1?4 ?p<N?  1?4 `?~<N?  13`?M? p 1>3M ? 0>3M ? 0~4L ? 0~3~K ? 03 ?J ? 03J 03 J 03|?J 02>>/?I 02w?H 02w`H 02{wsH ?0|29s0H ?0|2<gH?  ?1|2gGa  1<1|~S?G ? 1>1!8F ? 2>1`}|?F  21y}FF  21?#y?4E  20ypEÁ  20` E  20 E  2?0D?  2?/ C|?w??D?  2?/ ?|?O??D  2/ ?^D  2/!<?Ϟ?D  2/@|0C ? ?2/@>ߟxpC?  2/|qC?  3/~ϑ`C  3/ϼCC  3.?@? C?  ).܃߁ϟ|B?  ).￰?B  )-/?B  )?-_?_ BO  (-??ߞ?>B ? ?(?-?o~Bq  ?(?-?B1  (?-?B01 (?-?Bx (-x1g'?B ?&- A3{?B &,0A?A?&,}?~A?&+ý?x| ?A?&+?}x}?A> %?+?A< ?%?+@|%?+@?|%+@%+p;@???%?+@$+|ycKσ@ $+o`?߁@  $+a?@ ?   $+@ ? ? $+?#W@ ?  #+@;?   ?#+w?}?  #<p*??? ? #~p*?w?>  #~p*xyx?>?? ? #p*7?>?? "p*0?w>?? ?"p* ? >? &"~p* ~? &"<p*x}>? '"*~_>? '"*/o> '?!*ǿOa> '  ?ߟ?0  '  ?| ß0  ' !|?0  ( !??0  ( ?!<_?0 %? (? !9<0 %? ( !?3<1? % ( ?!m?~1 " ) ??!m{1 "O )? ?!^s?1 !' ) !_911 !! ) !x?1? ! ) "?1 ! ) !?~>1 !@ *? !??>?1 ! x *  ?>?1! p *  c? 1" 1*?  q?1"*  sg1"* ?s1'+?  &?'q1'+ &#q1'?+ 8'3?0' + ? '3s0' +? "<#;0' , "?<w0?'? ,  "0~??/& , "<~x/& ,?"xw}?_/?& -??!y_0& -!y?0? -!?y0 -!?q~0C - ?C=p1  0 .? ??1? σ . ???A1 /  ?|;??10  / ?~g??1x? ? / ?1   / Ã1?? . ?~1' |>? . p?1  ? -?  ?0  x? -  o0  <8? -  0  0? - !߀0 ?#  O? ,? ?!/ B? 0 , ?"/$!G|? , "߈/ ,  !w/?< ? , !<?1 ? + ??>1? ? + ?~?߇1 @ ? +?9?߀|!1 ?? + n}|1???? +? m~1~? ??? *?s=A1~ ?? *|wC1? ?? *?{C1? ?? *?}1? ~?? *?~??1 ?~? *??>?1 ?? )>??s1 ? )||81???? )?|1??? )??@1> )??o|1? )??y?1 (a1? (?1 ? (?8x0? (?|0? (?Ǚ?0 '?~|?0'?_70'?0 ?'??#?<'?#Dž?=x'$?c=&$8?>> & #?>8?&? #?>p ?&#/0>?  &#?~? %?#`@`1%?#?@%?#`?A%??#@߰5A@%?#oB>% ??# ~s<B?$ ?#~C$ #?~}?C$? ?#??~?D*$#~8 D*$# ~ E?)$$_@F)$$~F($$ǀG(%$G(% $?G(% ?$>x?]~H'% ?$?>~H'% ?$?>?H>'%? ?$???I&%!?$?I&%!?$??I~&%!?%߀J%%!?%p9K%%!?%<x?L~%%!%x>~>?L$&"%0<L&"%0`8M>&"%~M&"%??'p?MxJ%??;'`NJ%?OJ&?Ox*&~P ?)&@<8?s~P )?& |?xP >)?& ? pQ)?&3~  Q)?&>@?R(?&?xS?(?'?{T(?'@~T('?><U?('~?0V('|0?W('<?>x((x|y()`x|y8()0y()y()p?y()9|xz(* 8~pz?(*xz(*pz(*p>z<(+ <{~(?+ |{)?+ |{)+ x{?~), x|?x), x|), ǁ?|) ?- @}?) ?- }) ?-?}) .@~* .~* 0?p* 1?* * *? +? + + ?+ + ?, ?, , , ??,? , - . . ?. ?/ //?/0?1?12??22?23?44?4 ?5 ?6?6?6~67?7799:?~?>>?5&|-??( %>.??($<.??(?$?8.??($p.?*&?!.?*&".?*&".?*&">?.?*&"|. ? "?/@?~?p"??????/?@?~`!?~? /?|~@?!@0?>??>/<?|~~?!C>0~>?~?>>?/????!??/???!?????~/????!??????/????!??????/?????!???0????!???0???!?0???!?0???!???>0? ??!?|0????!?0????!??0????!??0????!?????1???!????1???!?????>1???!???|1????~?!?>????>1??~?!~????>??1???~?!~???2?>??!~???? 2?~>?!~? 5  x\ \? ?\? \?? \ \ \ \  ?\     ? ?     ?   ? 0 ??  @ C  ~ ??~~?>? >? >? >? >? ~>?~??~?~? ~? ~>? ~?? ~? ? ?? ? ? ?? >AA:\EGGS3.TIFWPC9 }&       ? ?     <???`??p|00<~`8!`???`<?  <~@?a?@?<~|~a??<>χ<~a???~?~~?a??~~?~~?`????~~?~~_????~~?~~.?>?,~?-~~~~a~??~??~????a>?~??~???a>?~?~??a?~~?~??a?~>?~?|??a?>~~?~?|a???>~??~?~?|a??~?~?~?a?~?~?!` ??C!??~ ?~??a`?8>??~?>?*|?1>?|??~?xpnnnn?nn?np"~~OW~W?~W?~Wp?~W|?~W|~W|~W~W ~W ?~W ~W ~W ~W ~V ~V ~V? ~V?  ?  ?f~V?  ? ?f~U? ? ?? ??f~U   ??f~S?  ??f~S  ??f~S  ??f~S  ??f~S  ??f~S1??d~S?2~??c~S2~??c~S?~2|~?c~S?2|~?~?~c~S 2????c~T? ?2?????c~T? 2?????c~T?0?????e~U?1??x?d~Ux 1??x?d~U ?1??x?d~U? 2??x?c~U< ?2??x?c~U ?2?a?x?c~V? 2???c~V 2???c~V 2????c~V 2???Ç?c~V 2??|??c~V 2????c~V ?2?????c~V ?2????c~V 2?~?c~V? 2??~!??c~V? 2??>?c~V 2?>?c~V ~V?~V~~V~?~V~?~Va|???~V|~V~V??~_~_~ - ~ ?- ~ - ~ - ~ -?~ -?~ -~ - ~ - ~ #  ~ -|#  ~ -8???#  ~ -??"  ~ -|?????"? ?~ -???" ?~ -??~?" ~ -~?"~ ,?"?~ ,~??"??? ~~ ,~? ??p??}~ -`?}~ -@?~?}~ -?>?~}~ ->?}~ ???}~ ?Ç????}~ Ç?????~?}~ -??}~ -?}~ -????}~ -???}~ -?? ??}~ -C ??}~ -?? ???~ -?! ?~ -?>?!? >?~]?? ??}~]? ??}~]? ?}~]? ? ??}~]?? ??}~] ?}~^  ?}~^? ?}~^ |?~~^~^?~^??~^?~^~^ ~^ ?~^ ?~^ ~^ ~^ ?~^ ?~^ ?~^ ?~^ ?~^ ?~j?~j?~j>~j>?~j?~B?~B~?C~?~?~~~~~?~?~?~~~ ~ ?~ ?~ ~ ?~ ~ ~!~!~!~!~!~!~!~!~!~!~!~!~!~!~!E~ ?E~ ?E~ ?D~ D~ ?D~ ?D~ D~E?~D~?D~?D~E~?E~ E~F~F~?F~?F~?F?~? ?~?? ~? ~? ~?? ~?? ~?? ~?? ~?? ~,?????~,??8`? ~?,??0?@? ~?,??  ~?,???? ~,???????~,??x?x?~,??xx?~?,?~?,